Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
C'était bien (avec la bonne fin)
J'étais un peu incertaine en débutant ce drame et finalement, après les deux premiers épisodes, j'étais plutôt emballée. Ce qui est assez étonnant quand on connaît mon passif difficile avec Idol Romance. Et pourtant ! Idol Romance met en lumière un potentiel qu'ils avaient caché jusqu'ici. Bien sûr (et comme c'est visible sur ma note), ce n'est pas parfait. Mais c'était bien mieux que ce qu'ils ont proposé par le passé. C'est sûr qu'avec Semantic Error en cours de diffusion, il est facile de faire pâle figure (j'ose), mais Kissable Lips s'en sort bien - c'est seulement la fin qui est boudée (à tord d'après moi).Le scénario est simple et bien géré. Étant un web drama, les épisodes sont ridiculement courts. La semaine des épisodes 5 et 6, j'ai eu l'impression de n'avoir rien vu. C'est gênant et cela impacte forcément le scénario et surtout le rythme du drama. Mais c'est récurrent (à croire que les BL sud-coréens n'ont pas le droit à des épisodes de 40 minutes). Pourtant, je n'ai pas trouvé l'écriture aussi chaotique que The Tasty Florida qui n'avait tout simplement aucun scénario - et qui possède une meilleure note (en tout cas, au moment où j'écris cette critique). Pas d'incohérences particulières et c'est (sur un aussi court format) un point bonus. Combien de web drama veulent traiter trop et ne s'achèvent pas correctement ? En fin de compte, le seul point que je ne suis pas sûre d'avoir compris est la raison pour laquelle Hae Soo a des yeux rouges, mais ce n'était pas comme si ça m'avait empêché d'apprécier l'ensemble.
J'ai vu quelques critiques sur le budget. Vous ne pouvez pas vous attendre à une Ferrari quand votre budget est celui d'une Polo (rien de mal contre les Polo, ce sont de très bonnes voitures en réalité, j'ai moi-même une Polo). Le budget semble bien réparti et nous épargne des effets spéciaux foireux - Jirisan et ses fonds verts, on en parle ? Certains drames chinois avec des effets abominables on en parle aussi ?
<< SPOILER >>
Pourquoi je vais à contre courant de la majorité des avis sur la fin ? Pour moi, c'était la fin idéale. Bien sûr, il y avait d'autres possibilités, mais est-ce que cela aurait dégagé le même sentiment, la même ambiance ? Je ne pense pas. Il ne faut pas seulement voir la mort de Jun Ho, il faut la comprendre. Il décide de mourir afin de laisser Min Hyun vivre. Il décide qu'il n'a aucun droit sur la vie de Min Hyun et accepte juste de disparaître, même s'il perd la personne qu'il aime - et qu'il l'abandonne. Et cela fait toute la différence. Parce qu'en fin de compte, mourir était moins douloureux que tuer la personne qu'il aimait. Et c'est en ça que la fin est parfaite.
Pour parler rapidement de l'anneau. Tout le monde semble déçu que Min Hyun ne le trouve pas. Et bien, encore une fois, je pense que c'était le bon choix. Quelle est la probabilité que Min Hyun trouve cet anneau ? Proche de zéro; soyons honnêtes. Ainsi, le fait qu'il ne le trouve pas est tellement plus réaliste. C'est comme un point manqué, comme cette opportunité ratée de la vie. Oui, c'est frustrant, mais...
<< /SPOILER >>
Le jeu d'acteur n'était aussi mauvais que mentionné dans certaines commentaires. D'accord, ça pouvait manquer de naturel et de fluidité de temps à autre, mais ce n'était pas aussi dramatique que ça. D'une certaine façon, le casting s'en sort bien. La musique était agréable et discrète. Quant à l'image, c'était un pur plaisir avec en prime beaucoup de prises à la lumière naturelle.
Peut-être que je prendrais le temps de le revoir en vostfr un jour ou l'autre. En attendant, je me sens un peu plus copine avec Idol Romance. En espérant que cela ne fera que continuer dans ce sens.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Mentally not okay anymore
I was warned that this would break me, and it did. I do get why people tend to give this a lower rate, due to the fact that it felt really rushed. The series is 8 episodes of just about 10 minutes and i watched it all in one sitting. If they gave me an 8 hour long series about this drama, i would still love it with all my heart.Im not really a big fan of sad endings, mostly because i want myself to maintain happy, but i think this story needed a sad ending. It was pretty obvious that one of them had to die. Min Hyun would not survive if Jun Ho decided to drink his blood. Although i think it would have been a beautiful ending if Jun Ho decided to drink Min Hyun's blood and Min Hyun survived, leading to the fact that they were now both human and could live together and have a happy ending, i think it would have been way to cliche. So thanks so much to the writer for me being able to still love a sad ending story.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
The ending surprised me
I don’t even know what I liked about it. There was a lot of things I didn’t like, I can tell you that, but I am finding it hard pointing out what I liked. The music was nice. The basic plot was interesting, but the execution was not good. The production value and acting were not the worst I have seen, but they weren’t amazing either.As I said, the plot had potential. But they didn’t really develop the characters enough, both the main two characters and the side characters. There was a lot going on that either didn’t make sense, was not properly addressed or it was just added in without any explanation. The flashback being shown a few times was unnecessary, especially for such a short series.
Kim Jun Ho & Choi Min Hyun: one is a vampire who is dying for killing a human, and the other is a human with pure blood that can turn a vampire into human. Jun Ho is someone we are supposed to feel sympathetic towards, but I found him very unlikeable most of the time. He had some good sides, but he was very hot and cold towards Min Hyun. I also hated how he strung Hae Soo along for hundreds of years. Min Hyun was sweet, but extremely naïve and with no regard for his own safety. Even after knowing the truth, knowing everything, he would still do whatever he felt like doing. I can understand why his brother wanted to know where he is 24/7.
The ending was not what I expected. And I really liked it, it made a lot of sense due to everything that has happened both in the past and present. I do wish it would have been done a bit differently, but I am not going to complain too much about that.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
I wasn't prepared..
Normally, I will look at reviews before watching a series, not necessarily to get spoilers but I do want to mentally prepare myself if a show will have a happy or sad ending. And, well, I didn't do that here and I'm kind of regretting it.Overall, it was a beautiful story about the struggle between self preservation and self sacrifice. At first, Jin Ho is all about self preservation and willing to trick Min Hyun into feeling for him in order to turn human. Then, as Jin Ho himself starts to catch feelings, he questions whether his "life" is worth the risk to Min Hyun's life. Meanwhile, Min Hyun struggles with the idea of losing Jin Ho and is willing to take the risk to try and help him with little regard to his own safety.
It may be a short series but it is filled with deep themes and potent emotions that leave the viewer wanting more. That being said, I wish the ending had been a bit different but I sort of see what they were going for. But it doesn't make for a high re-watch value for me, unfortunately.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Decent, for what it has
I was looking for some short series to fill some time and discovered this little show hidden away in the corners of someone’s favourites list.It’s a short show and I feel like the vampire lore/history isn’t very fleshed out, and the effects aren’t very good, but it’s still a nice wee show. The actors were actually really decent, and I didn’t mind the extremely rushed relationships because the actors managed to pull it off. It even has it’s own ‘Goblin’ moment that was devastating.
I think if this show was full length and not just ten minutes per episode (you can binge the whole series in an hour and a half) it would have been so much better; however, I do believe it does its job in being a neat mini series.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Time too short and plot inconsistent and confused!!
I think this series it started bad and it ended worst!! And i tell you why is like this: when first i read the plot on a website, my expectations were high, but then when i started them became low and in the beginning i thought i could give it a chance, probably it's only the first episode and usually it's not very good sometimes; but every time for me it was like a torture!!But the fault it's not for the actors, but the plot's inexistence!!
And whenever i watched the new episode i felt losted because they added random and useless characters and the time per each episode was too short to make a good storyline.
Eleven minutes per episode is too short for explain new things or adding new characters .
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
iliterallylovethis
1 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
This show was hilariously bad
As other people stated, the characters were all dumb. Another thing, this show was just way too melodramatic. It was so cringy. That's the only reason why I would recommend this show so that you can laugh at the theatrics.Because the show was so short, the couple wasn't really something you can ship that much. Like I couldn't believe they "loved" each other, but at least I could feel chemistry.
The worst thing about this show was the ending, lmaoooooooooo it was so bad. Like the plot had potential but they did so bad.
I think the show tried to pull people in with spicy scenes, but it's Korea, those scenes were barely anything. So overall the show wasn't that good and was a waste of time. At least the actors were adorable.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
An Unexpected Ending
This series consists of eight 10-minute episodes, totaling only 80 minutes. However, considering it as an 80-minute movie, the screenplay could have been much better.First of all, the screenplay was terrible. We never understand why the two characters fall in love so deeply. What was the reason for abandoning a 500-year life just to protect someone? There are also many gaps and lack of explanations throughout the story. The true identity of the university president is unclear. We don’t understand why the brother immediately recognizes the vampire and why Minhyung tells him, “You are a pure human.” The brother’s existence is puzzling and seems unnecessary. Despite his overprotectiveness, he continues to let his brother attend university even after realizing his life is threatened by a vampire. If I were in his shoes, I would have had him take a leave of absence or drop out of university.
Although I generally prefer happy endings, I liked that this series didn’t end happily. I thought that in the final scene, something miraculous would happen, and Minhyung wouldn’t die, leading to a happy ending for both characters. However, that didn't happen. It was a sad but satisfying ending, and I really appreciated that.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
A happy ending would've gotten an 8/10
but here we are. I have a real talent for picking BL's, blindly, that has a main character die in the last episode!The acting is good and the actors are handsome! The plot gets a 7.5 since the ending is sad. Like most K-BL's it suffers from one thing: too much plot and not enough screen time. I'm not sure where this issue originates, but it's so common I don't put all of the blame on the show if they do a good job with what they're given. By all accounts I think this show succeeded given the time allotment.
However, since this ending is sad I'm GLAD I didn't get more time to get attached to the characters since I hate a sad or unclear ending. 😭
I think it's worth watching once. Not the worst thing I've ever watched by far. It was something different and interesting!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Cute but stupid
This series is cute but stupid. With a total time of only about 80-90 minutes, you can easily watch it in one sitting. The actors are all adorable, and the romance is almost believable or as believable as it can get in such a sort series. The production quality is alright, and the glowing eyes is a nice touch.The thing that made me internally scream is the plot. The vampire pretty much just let himself die being unwilling to drink from his lover. Humans can lose about 50% of their blood without dying, and about 20% or so without even feeling any major side effects. Just do the blood drinking outside of a hospital or something and you're fine after some medical intervention. Better than one of you dying.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
DAMN THIS WOULD HAVE BEEN AMAZING!!! ??
Another short ass BL that had a great potential! If it weren't for how short it is, it would be amazing and compelling. This one is quiet unique from other BL being with supernatural characters which one of the main leads is a vampire. The pacing of the story is hella fast but i think I can follow. There were just like “this is the story” then they have been putting a bit of other story like another vampire guy who loves Jun Ho. I get it, Jun Ho needs a pure blood human to make himself a human but I don't understand the logic of being a vampire here like unaffected with the sunshine. They could have just made him afraid of sunlight and dislikes garlic or something like that. One I don't really think I get is that sucking another human with pure blood in the past then hunts another one which is Min Hyun which means like he's just another victim like he was not that special. I like the cast, I really do especially the main leads. The acting, is great you could tell. I really do like the chemistry of the two. The Osts are no joke!! Dream by SWAY made me cry so much (like shit, I can't) and the other osts of this drama are also good. I was really intrigued with the story but I think, it could have been better if they did not rushed it just like Enchanté and Star In My Mind. I think it's rushed. The story needs more polish and clarity. That's just the problem, how the story lost my interest for being such a short drama with short eps and running time. The director and the ones created this drama needs more time creating series just to see the full potential of it.Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Beautiful!
Left me Heart broken but full of hope and happiness at the same time! I need more vampire BL stories, especially not cliche ones! Those eight episodes within eleven minutes are pure gold where my mind isn't bored or goes wandering around. Perfect for optimal binge watching. I cried my egyes out but must say this story has (almost) perfect end (ofcourse I wish they grew old together)! But I am not sure if I will re-watch It in near future - too many feeling. Definitelly will recommend It (to my daughter, to ne honest).Considerați utilă această recenzie?