Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Great Chemistry; Weak Plot
"TharnType: The Series" is a BL drama that delves into the complexities of a relationship between two very different characters, Type, a homophobic university student, and Tharn, his openly gay roommate. The series attempts to tackle heavy themes such as homophobia, trauma, and the journey towards acceptance. While the story is compelling in its boldness, it is also problematic in several key areas, particularly in how it portrays the relationship between the main characters.
Story: The narrative of "TharnType" is intense, focusing on the evolution of Type from a deeply homophobic individual to someone who learns to accept and love another man. However, the journey to this point is fraught with problematic elements that can’t be ignored. The relationship between Tharn and Type is often toxic, characterized by manipulation, emotional abuse, and non-consensual encounters that are portrayed in a disturbingly romanticized light. These issues are not just brushed over but are, at times, depicted as part of the romantic development, which sends a troubling message about what constitutes a healthy relationship.
Tharn and Type’s dynamic is built on a foundation of conflict and power struggles. Type's initial aggression towards Tharn, fueled by his internalized homophobia and past trauma, creates a hostile environment. Tharn, on the other hand, is persistent, almost to the point of being coercive, in his pursuit of Type. This dynamic is problematic, as it blurs the lines between love and control, making it difficult to root for their relationship in a conventional sense. While the series attempts to explore the themes of redemption and healing, it often falls short by not addressing the toxic elements in a meaningful way, instead choosing to gloss over them in favor of an idealized romantic outcome.
Tharn and Type are both complex characters, each with their own set of flaws and virtues. Type, as a character, is initially hard to sympathize with due to his overt homophobia and volatile temper. His backstory reveals a traumatic experience that explains, but does not excuse, his behavior. Over the course of the series, Type undergoes significant character development, slowly coming to terms with his feelings for Tharn. However, this development is uneven, and his journey from hatred to love can feel rushed and inconsistent at times, especially considering the gravity of his initial prejudice.
Tharn, in contrast, is portrayed as a more emotionally mature and patient character, though his persistence can sometimes cross the line into problematic territory. His character is often seen as the more stable and caring partner, but his methods of dealing with Type’s aggression and resistance raise ethical questions. Tharn’s approach to winning Type over involves a level of manipulation and disregard for Type's boundaries, which complicates his role as the more sympathetic character. Despite these issues, Tharn’s unwavering love for Type is a central aspect of the series, driving much of the emotional weight of the story.
The complexity of both characters adds depth to the series, but it also highlights the toxic aspects of their relationship. While the show does attempt to depict their growth and the eventual softening of Type’s harsh exterior, it doesn’t fully address the unhealthy behaviors that are present throughout their relationship. This lack of resolution leaves the audience with mixed feelings about the characters and their journey together.
Cast/Acting: The standout aspect of "TharnType" is undoubtedly the chemistry between the leads, Mew Suppasit and Gulf Kanawut, who portray Tharn and Type. Their performances are compelling, with Mew bringing a gentle yet determined presence to Tharn, while Gulf convincingly portrays Type’s internal struggle and eventual transformation. The on-screen chemistry between Mew and Gulf is palpable, and it is this chemistry that drives much of the series' emotional weight. Their interactions, whether filled with tension, passion, or tenderness, feel genuine, pulling the audience into the intense dynamic between Tharn and Type. This chemistry is essential to the series’ success, as it keeps viewers invested in their tumultuous relationship, even when the narrative itself falters. Their performances are so strong that they elevate scenes that might otherwise feel cliché or problematic, making the series memorable despite its flaws.
However, while the lead actors excel, some of the supporting cast doesn’t quite match up. Many secondary characters lack depth, often serving as mere plot devices rather than fully realized individuals. This results in a less immersive world, where the focus remains heavily on the main couple, sometimes to the detriment of the overall story.
Music: Unmemorable.
Rewatch Value: "TharnType" has a certain rewatch value, especially for fans who are drawn to the intense chemistry between the leads. However, the series’ problematic elements, including the portrayal of toxic relationships and questionable consent, may make it difficult for some viewers to revisit. The heavy themes and the emotional toll of watching such a fraught relationship unfold might deter rewatching, especially for those who are sensitive to depictions of abuse or manipulation in romantic contexts. That said, certain scenes or moments, particularly those showcasing the lead actors’ chemistry, may still hold appeal for fans who are able to separate the problematic aspects from the overall experience.
Story: The narrative of "TharnType" is intense, focusing on the evolution of Type from a deeply homophobic individual to someone who learns to accept and love another man. However, the journey to this point is fraught with problematic elements that can’t be ignored. The relationship between Tharn and Type is often toxic, characterized by manipulation, emotional abuse, and non-consensual encounters that are portrayed in a disturbingly romanticized light. These issues are not just brushed over but are, at times, depicted as part of the romantic development, which sends a troubling message about what constitutes a healthy relationship.
Tharn and Type’s dynamic is built on a foundation of conflict and power struggles. Type's initial aggression towards Tharn, fueled by his internalized homophobia and past trauma, creates a hostile environment. Tharn, on the other hand, is persistent, almost to the point of being coercive, in his pursuit of Type. This dynamic is problematic, as it blurs the lines between love and control, making it difficult to root for their relationship in a conventional sense. While the series attempts to explore the themes of redemption and healing, it often falls short by not addressing the toxic elements in a meaningful way, instead choosing to gloss over them in favor of an idealized romantic outcome.
Tharn and Type are both complex characters, each with their own set of flaws and virtues. Type, as a character, is initially hard to sympathize with due to his overt homophobia and volatile temper. His backstory reveals a traumatic experience that explains, but does not excuse, his behavior. Over the course of the series, Type undergoes significant character development, slowly coming to terms with his feelings for Tharn. However, this development is uneven, and his journey from hatred to love can feel rushed and inconsistent at times, especially considering the gravity of his initial prejudice.
Tharn, in contrast, is portrayed as a more emotionally mature and patient character, though his persistence can sometimes cross the line into problematic territory. His character is often seen as the more stable and caring partner, but his methods of dealing with Type’s aggression and resistance raise ethical questions. Tharn’s approach to winning Type over involves a level of manipulation and disregard for Type's boundaries, which complicates his role as the more sympathetic character. Despite these issues, Tharn’s unwavering love for Type is a central aspect of the series, driving much of the emotional weight of the story.
The complexity of both characters adds depth to the series, but it also highlights the toxic aspects of their relationship. While the show does attempt to depict their growth and the eventual softening of Type’s harsh exterior, it doesn’t fully address the unhealthy behaviors that are present throughout their relationship. This lack of resolution leaves the audience with mixed feelings about the characters and their journey together.
Cast/Acting: The standout aspect of "TharnType" is undoubtedly the chemistry between the leads, Mew Suppasit and Gulf Kanawut, who portray Tharn and Type. Their performances are compelling, with Mew bringing a gentle yet determined presence to Tharn, while Gulf convincingly portrays Type’s internal struggle and eventual transformation. The on-screen chemistry between Mew and Gulf is palpable, and it is this chemistry that drives much of the series' emotional weight. Their interactions, whether filled with tension, passion, or tenderness, feel genuine, pulling the audience into the intense dynamic between Tharn and Type. This chemistry is essential to the series’ success, as it keeps viewers invested in their tumultuous relationship, even when the narrative itself falters. Their performances are so strong that they elevate scenes that might otherwise feel cliché or problematic, making the series memorable despite its flaws.
However, while the lead actors excel, some of the supporting cast doesn’t quite match up. Many secondary characters lack depth, often serving as mere plot devices rather than fully realized individuals. This results in a less immersive world, where the focus remains heavily on the main couple, sometimes to the detriment of the overall story.
Music: Unmemorable.
Rewatch Value: "TharnType" has a certain rewatch value, especially for fans who are drawn to the intense chemistry between the leads. However, the series’ problematic elements, including the portrayal of toxic relationships and questionable consent, may make it difficult for some viewers to revisit. The heavy themes and the emotional toll of watching such a fraught relationship unfold might deter rewatching, especially for those who are sensitive to depictions of abuse or manipulation in romantic contexts. That said, certain scenes or moments, particularly those showcasing the lead actors’ chemistry, may still hold appeal for fans who are able to separate the problematic aspects from the overall experience.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?