Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Historia desperdiciada
He terminado de ver el drama por qué ya había invertido tiempo en el desde que empezó a emitirse, sentí el deber de terminar, pero sinceramente final forzado y plano.Porque? ( mezclare lo que me gustó y no me gustó):
1. Historia "sobrenatural": creo que la historia inicial era atrapante, que haría un demonio poderoso en el mundo humano? Con esa premisa premisa en mente, el drama me atrapó en los primeros capítulos. Sin embargo, esa "humanización" del FL la sentí vacía, superficial y plana, hubo escenas dramáticas, sí, pero el romance entre ML y FL (la cual fue la razón para que FL se humanice) me pareció soso, sin química, forzado, poco natural de ese amor/odio inicial que mostraron. En otras palabras la historia pudo ser mejor si no se hubiera centrado en la premisa de que "el amor todo lo puede y lo cambia, para bien" lo que hace que esa premisa sea un cliché mal entendido. (3/10)
2. La FL (PSH) Justitia/Kang BitNa: el desempeño de la FL en pantalla me gusto (hasta cierto punto) la he visto en otros dramas y creo que aquí se esforzó para desempeñar un papel mezcla entre cínico y amable, sin embargo, sorry! La sentí como una actuación forzada, definitivamente amo a PSH en otros dramas, le aplaudo querer caracterizar algo poco común en sus papeles, sin embargo, pudo ser más "oscuro y creíble". Siento que su papel como Justitia perdió fuerza (6/10)
3. Humor: si! Fue un poco relajante las escenas de humor en las interacciones con los personajes secundarios, sinceramente se me hicieron divertidos, y en casos, rozando lo ridículos. (8/10)
4.Juicios: los primeros juicios creo que fueron disfrutables, algunas escenas un poco reforzadas en cuanto a coreografía de lucha cuerpo a cuerpo, sin embargo, para saciar la "sed de venganza" ante la indignación por personajes despreciables no estuvo mal (8/10)
5. ML (HDO): aunque guapo e interesante al principio, el personaje se ablando al final, perdiendo su carácter independiente, ni siquiera se invirtieron los papeles entre ML y FL, si no que el ML se volvió más plano, dependiente, super emocional y como un ser necesitado de que alguien lo defienda, como policía al final su papel fue plano. (4/10)
6. Secundarios: fueron divertidos, pintorescos y le dio un buen sustento a los FL y ML, sus emociones bien expresadas (me gustó el papel de la madre de Yechan). (8/10)
7. Satanás: el personaje me encantó, más en su forma original, pero me pareció que no enriqueció mucho la historia, solo fue una argucia para disminuirle la pena de Justitia.
8. Final: Terrible! Sacrificaron la historia por el romance, nooo! Un final capitulo 14 innecesario, largo, plano, a excepción del juicio del asesino J. No entendí porque Justitia en el infierno no tomo su forma original, y siguió en el cuerpo de BitNa, cuando otros demonios retornaron con su verdadera identidad. El apoyo del ángel Gabriel y la intervención de Dios... Hace quedar a la idea de Dios como una broma, ya que entonces, para que infierno? Y claro, ella sigue en su misión de matar a los "malos" aún teniendo la consciencia del sufrimiento de las víctimas, todo en base a que se humanizo y que los humanos no entienden los designios superiores de Dios o del diablo.... Sinceramente aburrido. (1/10)
9.Ost: varios temas del OST me gustaron. El intro principal con su canto lírico, si! (8/10)
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
EymiLaritzaJorgeCastillo
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Increíble
La historia de un demonio que es juez en el infierno y es castigada por sentenciar incorrectamente a una jueza que llego al infierno siendo "Inocente" y que tendrá que matar a una cantidad e asesinos en el mundo humano para poder volver al infierno o sino morirá.La premisa me encanto desde el inicio y cada episodio me dejo mas intrigada en que pasaría, ame a ver a Park Shin Hye en este papel, fue diferente a lo que he visto de ella anteriormente y le quedo perfecto.
Aunque la historia gira entre la vida y la muerte y el infierno, hubo cavidad para el romance y en especial la actuación del beso del ultimo ep fue la mejor en ese ámbito, lo recalco, porque siempre dicen que las escenas de ella en este aspecto son fatales.
Sobre las actuaciones en general, pues fueron muy buenas y me encantaron, fueron geniales todos, y en mi opinión sentí que transmitían en cada momento.
En cuanto a la musica, uff ame este OST desde la canción principal hasta la musica de ambiente, sentí una correcta musicalización en la serie, al menos en mi opinión, no sentía forzada la musica y veía que transmitían bastante de la escena solo con ella.
Sobre el final, no dare spoilers, pero si me gusto lo ultimo del final, fue genial, sobre el rostro, si creo que si hubiera sido mensos largo mejor.
Sin duda una serie que tuvo de todo, especialmente venganza, me gusto que aunque tuvo romance, nunca fue el foco principal y tuvo la dosis perfecta en la historia, algunas cosas si puedo decir que las sentí mas simple, especialmente algunas escenas entorno al final, pero de igual manera el desarrollo en general fue divino, y la historia se sentía ligera y disfrutable desde el inicio.
Espero seguir viendo a estos actores en diferentes papeles en el futuro, realmente me creí la historia de todos!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Expectations Met and Lost
First off, the show is an absolute watch. I remained hooked from the first episode to the last... Had to take breaks though since I'm not really into the dark themes 😅.The overall theme of justice was very moving and I found me asking myself the hard questions on my own sense of justice and that around me. I think having a 'judge from hell' showed the failings of the human laws especially in dealing with those who have the means to pay their way out... but also how the law can be manipulated for other crimes, because in all essence, Kang Bit Na made her rulings according to the law. It also depicted quite literally what it means to take the law into your own hands and the 'true justice' scenes were amazing to watch as the tables are tuurned on the criminals. I like that this was consistent throughout the drama.
Kim Da On's character was interesting in its evolution. From the easy beguilement when he liked the judge thinking she was on his side, to the rejection when their views clashed and the ultimate choice to side with a demon for his own goals...His character feels very human being that it is being contrasted against a demon who has very different rules for her own court. His cuteness was very endearing to watch.
In the overall direction of the drama, my expectations from the blub and trailer were met. The cast was amazing, the acting great, the OST (mostly the croossroads one) an earworm but the story kind of fizzled out in some areas. We're shown KBN ending up in hell by mistake and Justitia taking possession of her body, but even as the story ends we still don't know what happened to the real KBN...It honestly wouldn't have been a problem if somehow in 30secs we're shown her being sent to the right place, but there're scenes where she's running/discovering hell which gave the expectation that she'd return somewhere down the line. Also, does this mean that even for the other possesions those people ended up in hell by accident? I also expected the scene where KBN would return to hell we'd have the 'original' Justitia since she had a different face from KBN...Satan's fight was waay underwhelming, I thought he was second to Baal! I honestly expected Justitia to summon Bael to fight him since she's lower ranked than him....For all the power Bael showed at the beginning, he ended up being a redundant demon, basically playing a messenger between Justitia and Lucifer. I was even confused about the deal to make Justitia human when in the entire drama she didn't show any inclination of wanting to be one. So was Bael being a good master/plotting something?
The romance was 50/50 for me. The scenes and moments were cute and endearing but some felt out of place. When the humanizing changes started happening, it felt wrong to assume that it was love based on the character settings for the drama. Everyone telling KBN that she was in love made her beleive it too. Don't get me wrong, but I felt with the emphasis that was being placed on the lady judge statue, the development of emotions would have been developed torwards why her eyes were covered or something... Also why is love the only treasonous emotion and how is it okay for Arong get away with obsessing over Justitia to the point of interfering with her romance?
My review is kinda all over the place(sorry) and ended up being a ranting(very sorry)... But the show is amazing to watch, its just some plot holes that were left unfilled.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Hungry_Hippo91
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Bell curve
Why are drama writers not in favour of writing strong female charcters without any romantic attachments??Kang Bitna becomes the Nth Strong FL who is bogged down by forced romance and fumbled character development.
Park Shin hye was clearly having the time of her life with Kang Bitna (Please write such witty sassy characters for her, dont pidgenhole her into moppy romantic FLs.). While Kim Jae Young literally plays the damsel in distress. Why did the writers think its a good idea to ruin the ML's character with poor writing. The shift from a confident no nonsense cop to one to the damsel in distress was awful to watch(grave injustice to KJY). They wasted the drama's potential by not exploring a platonic relationship between them. Moreover the runaway devil subplot was way more interesting than the serial killer one. And I am not even touching the choices made for Bitna's character by the writers.
the uneveness made me feel like I was watching 2 different dramas. The first 8 episodes were a solid 9/10 while the 2nd half felt like 6/10.
But even with all its flaws I loved that PSH took up such a role and hope to see her in similar roles like this.
This not a bad drama, but if your willing to overlook its short comings, do give it a try.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
An addicting drama not going to lie
I really enjoyed this drama most especially Park Shinhye and her wonderful acting. I would love a s 2nd seasons. I watched for Park Shinhye and stayed for Kim Jaeyoung. I've never seen him in a drama before but I will be on the lookout for his new projects and watching his older ones.The story does take a turn towards the end that seem a bit unsatisfying, but the drama is still a good one. Oh and holy crap LeeKyuhan's acting had me screaming. He really does play his role perfectly. I would say definitely watch this one.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
DRAMAAAAAAA!!!!! akting park shin hye yg udh gabisa diragukan lagi apalagi dengan masa karir nya yg udah melejit sedari kecil, dan akting kim jae young yang mengimbangin shin hye, menurutku jae young di drama ini bener bener berbeda dari drama sebelumnya, begitu juga dengan park shin hye. shin hye yg biasanya memainkan karakter dengan latar belakang yang tidak memiliki apa apa kini memainkan karakter yang tidak ber empati dan mati rasa. serta jae young di drama ini yang terlihat lebih mencolok dan menarik perhatian para penonton tjfh dengan sangat mudahnya. BEST DRAMA IN 2024!!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
clairethecapricorn
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Judge from Hell was a ton of fun and it far surpassed my low expectations for it. Park Shin-hye was iconic as Kang Bit-na. She was hilarious and also did a great job with the many action scenes. She really showed her range. The revenge sequences as she sends murderers to hell were great and watching her strut away from the crime scenes was so memorable. The back and forth between her and Han Da-on was always fun to watch and they had great chemistry. While the romance felt a little underdeveloped, I still really liked them together.
The show could’ve benefitted from a few more episodes, if only because it would’ve allowed time for expansion of plot lines that felt forgotten. I really thought we were going to see more of actual Kang Bit-na in hell and that felt like a bit of a loose thread. Some of the characters also felt wasted, like Bael who could’ve been a lot more interesting but just fell a little flat. The plot also felt unnecessarily complicated towards the end, with so many different villains, some of whom were wearing other faces. I would’ve preferred to have a little more of the revenge and a little less of the convoluted plot at the end.
I think that Park Shin-hye really put on such a fun show that regardless of any plot issues I might have had, I really had a great time watching. She was effortlessly funny and over the top, but in a way that made sense for the story and character. I think she’d be so much fun to see as a true villain in another project because the energy she had in the revenge scenes could work so well in a project like that!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Beautifully written storyline!!
I loved the storyline honestly, alot of people said some things were pathetic but that is their opinion. I love the fact that even after Kang Bin na started to feel more human-like they did not falter her judgements towards the criminals. And ofcourse she is a demon, her main task was to kill the sinners, no matter how.The chemistry between Bin na and Daon however did feel slightly forced, they looked cute together. It was perfect when they were secretly falling for eachother but in the last episode it felt a bit forced and awkward.
However both the actors gave their best. Executed their roles perfectly and no one else would have fit better than them!!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Don't judge Hell by its cover!
Without spoilers, all I can say is that this show deserve the hype, BUT it's not perfect!The first half of the season was a HELLA FUN! Park Shin Hye as Bit Na carried the whole show, and that's not even surprising. Honestly, at first I thought we're gonna get some weekly cases, but that doesn't really happen. The overall story was good, but predictable, especially if this isn't your first fantasy Kdrama. I had some problems with the writing, because even tho I don't like when they say everything out loud, the case of real Bit Na and what happened to her would be nice to know without doing research online.
The biggest issue with the show is probably the fact that it lacks consistency. The problem with fantasy shows in general is that the writers creating a world and rules that they can't follow later on, because if they would, they need to kill the main characters. I don't want to talk about the mythological part of the show, because it wouldn't make any sense, but the plot armor helped the main characters a lot, because there's no way in hell (no pun intended) Bit Na is stronger than her leaders.
Also, even tho the main leads were cute and all, I think they were better as a bickering frenemies than lovers! I think the romance is kind of took out the fun from the show, but it's not a big deal. I just didn't felt they had a great chemistry as a couple.
The main story with the serial killer and the families were amazing, where the show really shines is the drama, the comedy, and the action.
For me, the best "couple" of the show is easily BitNa, aka "Soon To Be Dead" and the "Old Hag"! That part is still making me laugh!!!😂 Park Shin Hye and Kim Young Ok were absolutely amazing together!
The OST and a Score is also great, especially the latter, and props to the director and cinematographer, and of course the VFX team! This isn't really a big budget Kdrama, yet it still looked great!
I'm not sure if we're gonna get a 2nd season, but if we will, I'm gonna watch it for sure, because this was entertaining!
If you can look past on the flaws and just enjoy what you get, you won't be disappointed!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Nini_is_watching
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Must watch
I really enjoyed this one.Good storytelling and great acting. Park Shin Hye shined. It’s too bad that she was typecast in “pity me, look i cry pretty” roles early in her career. But she definitely showed her doubters in this series that she’s one of the best actresses in the industry.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Fantasy ,, Good story ,, Great acting (from Shin Hye)
Story plot:The story is good and kinda new. the fantasy was exciting but they should have elaborated on the demonic powers and limitations. Some parts could have been written better as they don't add up like they should.
Some scenes would have been more exciting and events should have been thought through to make more sense.
I didn't feel bored most of the show but it could be cut down to 12 or smth. The best part was Shin Hye's acting.
Acting:
Park Shine Hye's acting is 10/10 but that male lead is not as strong and not meticulously crafted I'll give him 6/10 since he did his part. If the lead actors had had more chemistry it would have been much better. I liked all the other characters they were written just right.
Takeaways:
- They weren't much chemistry between the lead actors, the romance could have been elevated a lot, it was a bit disappointing.
- It was nice overall and I would say it's worth watching.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
เปิดมาดีมากๆ ช่วง 3 ตอนแรกชอบมาก แต่พอไปเรื่อยๆเริ่มเฉยๆ ยิ่งพอนางเอกเริ่มชอบพระเอกแล้วดรอปลงเลย ตอนแก้แค้นเหมือนจะสะใจแต่ส่วนตัวว่าเฉยๆ ดูแบบไปเรื่อยๆ นางเอกเล่นดีมากๆๆ พระเอกเล่นพอได้ไม่ถึงกับแข็งไม่ถึงกับอินแถมบทน่ารำคาญอยู่หน่อยๆ
แต่จบดี เดาไว้อยู่แล้วว่าไม่น่าจะ bad end คงสมหวังไม่ก็ปลายเปิด ก็เป็นตามนั้น
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
