I enjoyed every episode and moment. Though pacing is pretty slow in the first episodes, later on the story catches up greatly.
Would highly recommend.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
One of my favorite dramas of all time. This is an emotional, cute and at times heartbreaking ride. This review contains some spoilers
I've been following Kim So Hyun's works since I saw and loved her in Missing You. Really, she became one of my favorite korean actresses, everything about her is so natural and sincere, her acting really gets you on the character's skin and makes you laugh and cry whenever she does. One of the most promissing(if not the most) actresses out there. But the show doesn't resume on her acting, I also thought Yook Sung Jae did an excelent job as the problematic yet quirky Tae Gwang. Seriously, he and So Hyun had such chemistry...(I'm still butthurt because they didn't end together)
Gushing aside, the story was also pretty well executed, with just some flaws and plot holes here and there. I know that this amnesia plot is extremely overused, but instead of just being used as a plot device, the amnesia is well developed and it even helps on the development of Eun Bi. Seriously, she goes from a girl who lost her courage, to someone who could impersonate her twin's attitude and then changed (again) to someone who could fend for herself and face her problems instead of running away.
The love triangle was also well executed, but poorly solved. *SPOILER* Really, I can't believe that they built such a relationship between Eun Bi and Tae Gwang, only for her to end up with the guy that spent basically the entire drama longing for her sister. I'm still pissed at this.
Another thing that could be promissing but ended up poorly executed was Eun Byl's character. Really, the girl was like no other I've seen in dramas (at least so far) and I surelly wanted to see more of her, and therefore more a development for her character. It was like a breath of fresh air when she finally showed up and gave the bully girl what she deserved. I was the entire time cheering: "You go girl!" Also, kudos for Kim So Hyun for managing to deliver two completely different characters.
Also, apart from romance and characters, I really liked the way this series handled issues like bullying. It was very saddening to see how much one is willing to hurt the other only because of their own internal struggles. Even though I didn't like the character one bit, I have to congratulate Jo Soo Hyang's job, because it was so well done that she made me really hate her but at the same time sort of understanding where she came from.
All in all, it was a very good drama. I openly recommend you to watch and fall in love with this coming of age story.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
I just finished watching this drama, i have something to express that i can't hold back. First, kim so hyun was overwhelming in her double role, how she managed to portray a tempered strong fascinating girl loved by her friends and another mild mannered calm and tidy girl who was bullied in her previous school. I can't describe this drama with words; the fact that the twins both existed was epic and that eun byul stopped kang so young from bullying and forced her in the end to be remorseful is a big deed. But Tae kwang is the lead that was oppressed he was the first one who acknowledged eun bi as herself, and was heated up that she cared for him but she didn't shared his feelings in the end was a bit disappointing even if eun byul and Han I yan were not true lovers just best friend, it would be more fair that eun-bi like Gong tae kwang who did everything for and not han I yan who was confused between her and eun-byul. The other sides of the story were somehow interesting: min joon and his mom, jung soo In case etc...In overall, this drama was really enjoyable, it deserve a high rating because of the actors especially the splendid kim so hyun, however the love story was lacking.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
This show made me have my second lead syndrome for the first time. I don't like the goody two shoes second leads but this time..the second lead blew my heart. Obviously he is damn amazing coz he is Yook Sung Jae.
The main female lead obviously acts very well according to her age. Plus she is pretty. Both of her roles were opposite and she played them so well.
Even the negative lead was so good she actually made us hate her from the bottom of our heart XD
The story will never bore you ...you will be like what will happen next and all.
So if you even have a question about watching it...forget it. You should just watch it. You will not regret.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Kim Sohyun you give me another chance to live.
#fighting
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
gumho_starlight
1 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Başlarda çok hoşuma gitti karakterler, mekanlar, kıyafetler filan. Hepsi şirindi, ilginçti. Zorbalık konusuna iyi değinilmişti. İkizlerin yer değiştirmesi olsun, Su-İn olayı olsun kafa karıştırıcı ve merak uyandırıcıydı. Tae Gwang karakteri çok sevimliydi ve onu izlemek çok hoşuma gitti, ilgimi çekti. Ama bir süre sonra dizi dinamikliğini kaybetti ve ağırlaşmaya başladı. Uzun bakışmalar, lafı uzatmalar, beylik laflar... Sakız gibi uzattılar da uzattılar. O kadar sıkıcılaştı ki neredeyse bırakıyordum. Dizide aşırı aşırı aşırı fazla boş sahne var. İnsanın içi daralıyor.
Over-dramatic sahneler git gide arttı. Birinin tam gidecekken diğer kişinin "Ya, Eun-Bi!" diye durdurması ve arkadan konuşması. Bu bir bölümde en az 3-4 kere oluyor. Birinin diğerini kolundan tutarak sürüklemesi. Yani o kadar bıktım ki anlatamam. Birinin bi şeye kulak misafiri olması, görmemesi gereken bi şeyi görmesi... O kadar klişe ki.
Ayrıca aşırı AŞIRI AŞIRI rahatsız edici bir şey var. Ses yönetmenlerinin bunu fark edip düzeltmemiş olmasını kınıyorum gerçekten çok büyük bir gerizekalılık. İnsanlar konuşurken ağızları şaplıyor. Özellikle Su İn'in ablası ve inek erkek öğrencinin ağzı aşırı şaplıyor. Su İn'in ablası konuşurken dizinin sesini kıstım resmen, Eun Bi'yi okulda karanlıkta kapattığı bölümde. O KADAR İĞRENÇ Kİ KULAĞIMI KESMEK İSTEDİM. O KADAR İĞRENÇTİ Kİ. HAYATTAN SOĞUDUM. NE KADAR SİNİRLENDİĞİMİ VE KUSMAK İSTEDİĞİMİ ANLATAMAM YA.
Bunların dışında karakterlerin iç dünyalarına ve hayatlarına iyi değinilmişti. Karakterlerin hepsi gerçekçiydi. Eun-Byol'Un arkadaşları filan mesela. Çok güzeldi yani iyi işlenmişti.
Eun-Bi'nin kişilği AŞIRI sıkıcı ya AŞIRI. O kadar sevmiyorum ki. Çok boş. Üff.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
School series in particular have this specific way to delve deeply into the problems of South Korean students. Who Are You: School 2015 was based on bullying and common family problems. Also, this version offered a lot of mystery elements which I really enjoyed. Sometimes it felt like you were reading a crime novel!
The storyline was quite hard to follow, especially in the first episode, but the eventually everything started to fall into place. I get why a lot of people like to be harsh critics of School 2015 (probably the second lead syndrome that everyone has gone through). Yes yes, there were so beautiful moments portrayed by the skillful actors, whom I already recognize from the previous drama that they've starred in. Some characters in particular made me mad and sappy, happy and sentimental. My emotions were all over the place and I guess it's supposed to be the main objective of the drama.
The OST was touching and enjoyed as well. Can't help but replay all of the songs after watching it!
If you're into school themed dramas that deal with teen problems and first love, this is the drama for you! The storyline is gripping, the actors are superb and the music will definitely enchant you!
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
nothingbutdrama
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
i think this best drama theme school , but why school 2015 have low ratting in korea? so is popular drama
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
deu não, pulei fora...
achei que o mistério que criaram foi interessante de início, mas depois, ficou tudo muito confuso... não gostei muito e não tive paciência pra continuar.o que dizer sobre a atuação? achei mediana, exceto pelo sungjae, que me chamou atenção positivamente!
a ost é maravilhosa! quem nunca se pegou ouvindo reset?
pensei em tentar assistir novamente, mas tenho a sensação de que vou estar perdendo meu tempo, principalmente levando em conta que tem outros doramas melhores por aí hoje em dia.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?