My Love Mix-Up! (2024)

NOT THE BEST VERSION!

I love Gemini and Fourth both as actors and as acting couple, but this is not their best work.
Unfortunately it happened automatic for me the comparison with the japanese version, since I have watched it first years ago.
For me the japanese one was the best one: the actors were perfect for their characters in the drama, I also loved the delicacy with which the story was approached and the secondary characters were always inserted into the story in the right way and at the right time. They were never an extra.
Gemini and fourth are good actors, I loved them in "My school president" and I loved even more their characters in "Moonlight chicken" so I don't doubt their acting skills. But this was not their drama.
Maybe if I didn't watch the japanese version, I could've thought differently, doing no comparison. But the reality is different.
I have tried to watch this version until the very end only for gemini and fourth, but I couldn't.
In general, the drama has a very good plot so I can't say anything about it.
BUT IF YOU WANT MY OPINION, GO WATCH THE ORIGINAL VERSION E LEAVE THE THAILANDESE ONE APART AND IF YOU WANT TO SEE GOOD WORKS OF GEMINI AND FOURTH THEN GO TO WATCH THE DRAMAS THAT I HAVE NAMED BEFORE.

Citeste mai mult

are gemfourth really the protagonists?

Ok hear me out, I don't have anything against any actor and I don't blame any of them, this is more to the production and writers.

I started mlmu for gemfourth and bc I watched the original one (the Japanese) so I was really excited, the first ep were good (no the editing and colors) it was funny and entertaining but then it seems like gemfourth were not the main couple and I was confused cause I their story was the one I was interior. I don't understand what's the matter with having a straight couple which is suppose to be like a little extra and give them more focus than the main one?? their story was boring as hell and I ended up skipping their scenes. they could have made one of the best gemfourth series but ruined it with the excessive sound effects, terrible editing, bad story, bad direction etc. the only good thing was gemfourth and the ost. I feel so sorry for them cause they are amazing actors and deserve a better better for their next bl

Citeste mai mult

No geral gosto muito de Gemini e Fourth: acho os dois fofos, bonitos e bons atores. Mas acho que, depois do sucesso de My School President, a GMMTV está tentando a todo custo manter a "ingenuidade" do ship, e acabamos com um casal de protas com caras de marmanjo (lindos por sinal), mas fazendo papel de colegiais que se limitam a dar "selinhos". Eles cresceram, e gostaria de vê-los em papeis mais marcante e que valorizassem mais o talento dos dois. A história não é ruim, é fofa mas é muito "água com açúcar", ao ponto de, em alguns momentos, se tornar chata. Respeito o trabalho dos meninos, mas eles precisam de mais...

Citeste mai mult

La inocencia del primer amor

He de decir, antes de empezar, que no he tenido la oportunidad de verme Kieta Hatsukoi aún, por lo que esta reseña no nace de la comparativa.

La historia es sencilla: una equivocación lleva a dos chicos a acercarse. Y en esa cercanía, verán nacer el primer amor.

Gemini y Fourth son adorables. Se nota que son jóvenes y que tienen mucho camino por recorrer, pero se esfuerzan y disfrutan de lo que hacen.

Quizá, de todos los personajes, los que peor escritos están son los que giran alrededor de Mudmee, pero no me sorprende encontrar personajes femeninos escritos de manera pobre. No es la peor que me he encontrado en esta industria ni de lejos.

Creo que la GMMTV tiene un plantel joven muy potente, que ofrecerá producciones de gran calidad en los próximos años.

Ya tengo ganas de saber qué les espera a GeminiFourth como ship y como promesas individuales.

Citeste mai mult

a show that even gem4th couldn't save.

it started out fine imo, I actually enjoyed it for the first 5-6 episodes. Fourth did a great job as atom. but then it got so so so stagnant at one point, almost sickeningly so.

the product placement might be the most annoying part, if I see one more euro cake ad, I will flip my table over.

I also feel like they could have expanded more on kongthap's character, especially when they do give a lot of depth to Atom's. it feels like an imbalance, where kongthap became a side character in his own story.

mudmee and half stole the show, although half just played the role of "Huh, what's happening here? I'm lost." for two thirds of the series.

it's just incredibly funny that at the end of the day, mudmee, a side character, had more depth to her than kongthap, the lead character.

I held hopes for this series even when most people dropped it, but it did kind of disappoint me.

one plus point is that I absolutely love the music for this series <3

Citeste mai mult

A disaster..

Being already a fan of the manga, it was my most anticipated series of the year only to be left really disappointed. For the most part, the show stays loyal to the original material with all the necessary changes for cultural reasons, but the execution failed miserably. The story was buried under product placements and mass merch endorsement, one that I've never seen in any other bl going that hard. Some scene additions were totally unnecessary as well, offering nothing other than dragging the pace, when there was so much material to adapt already. All that combined with very childish music choices on the background. In all honesty, after a point I watched the episodes fast forward just to get on with it, with the only exception being the intro and the outro song, which I loved very much.

As for the cast, it couldn't have been more perfect. These four actors were excellent for the roles and did their best, but even with their skills I didn't manage to connect with the characters at all. And when the writing suffers there's so much an actor can do.

Despite all that, I do recommend this series to anyone who just wants to see a very fluffy and non dramatic story. It has its cute and fun moments here and there and if that's the type of series you enjoy you could give it a try.

Citeste mai mult

So... what happened?

I noticed the low ratings before starting to watch this series, so all my expectations lowered from the beginning. I wasn't expecting MLMU to be exceptionally good or exceptionally bad: I just hoped I would enjoy it at least a little.
In the end, I did enjoy it, but I also feel like that enjoyment came from a handful of different moments here and there, all engulfed of very long and draggy segments. Oh, and lots of different product placements - probably the most invasive case of advertisements I've ever seen in a GMM series.

I don't think anything reached its true potential here.
- The main plot points of Kieta Hatsukoi worked in the Japanese drama, which consisted in 10 episodes of about 20 minutes each, but it felt very diluted in these 12 episodes of about 40 minutes each. After enjoying the first three or four episodes, I started getting impatient and frustrated while watching, and often found myself too bored to even pay attention during the important bits.
- The characters felt flat. The acting was amazing and I'm not taking it back, but it was hard to watch such good actors work with characters written so poorly. At their best they felt like caricatures, and they felt like cardboard cutouts at any other moment.
- Kongthap and Atom felt more like classmates who get along rather than potential lovers, and even their friendships with other characters didn't feel as sincere as they should have. Some scenes were heart-fluttering, but they felt like they were put there to make the relationships work, when it should be the exact opposite: the rest of the story was supposed to make the romantic moments hit the spot, but they never delivered fully for this exact reason.
- There were multiple themes for the series that could have been included and explored much better, but they weren't. Whoever wrote this didn't put any true passion into the story and didn't care to fix any continuity issues.

In theory, this series is supposed to work. The director and the main actors are the same as in My School President, which I've enjoyed A LOT, and the source material is a pretty good Japanese BL. In practice, it really looks like the production team threw these elements together (Fourth, Gemini, several MSP references, and the Kieta Hatsukoi plot points) and just expected things to work fine without putting extra work into it.
Since I don't like to make comparisons between series in my reviews, I'd rather avoid making them here, but it's truly hard not to. The main reason why I felt so frustrated is because I've watched Fourth and Gemini in My School President and Moonlight Chicken before, so I know that they can truly shine when the production team puts actual care in the quality of their work.

If this is your first Thai series, or you never watched My School President nor Moonlight Chicken, this can work as a cute, low-effort rom-com, as long as you have no high expectations for it. If that's not the case, then you're probably going to be very disappointed.

Citeste mai mult

My Love Mix-Up Thailand - A Mixed Bag of Expectations

GMMTV’s adaptation of Kieta Hatsukoi—a Japanese Yaoi manga by Hinekure Wataru—is a curious endeavor. The original series, which was also adapted into a Japanese BL drama in 2021, brought a fresh and charming story to life. So, when I heard GMMTV was creating a Thai version, I’ll admit I had my reservations. The Japanese series had its quirks, and I wondered how this would translate into the world of Thai BL. As a fan of both the manga and the original show, I went in with cautious optimism.

The premise of My Love Mix-Up! Thailand remains true to its source material. We have Atom, played by Fourth Nattawat, who is a timid and somewhat clumsy high schooler with a crush on his classmate Mudmee (Pahn Pathitta). His world is turned upside down when a simple mix-up leads Kongthap (Gemini Norawit) to believe Atom has a crush on him, setting off a series of misunderstandings and comedic moments.

Right from the start, the series felt like it was missing something. There’s a certain magic in storytelling that pulls you in, makes you root for the characters, and keeps you invested. Unfortunately, My Love Mix-Up! Thailand struggled to find its footing. For a series with such a light-hearted and fun premise, it often felt like it was dragging its feet.

Fourth Nattawat’s portrayal of Atom was lackluster at best. He’s a talented actor, and I’ve seen him shine in other roles, but here it felt like he was holding back. Perhaps it was the character itself or maybe the direction, but whatever it was, it didn’t quite hit the mark. Gemini Norawit as Kongthap had moments of brilliance, particularly in scenes where his stoicism came into play, but overall, it felt like both actors were coasting rather than fully embodying their roles.

One of the biggest downfalls of the series is the excessive product placement. Now, I understand that sponsorship is a necessary evil in today’s media landscape, but there’s a fine line between subtle integration and blatant advertising. Unfortunately, My Love Mix-Up! Thailand crossed that line repeatedly. The product placements were so jarring that they often pulled me out of the story entirely. It’s a real shame because it distracted from the chemistry that could have developed between the characters.

Speaking of chemistry, Gemini and Fourth have it in spades. We’ve seen it before in Moonlight Chicken and My School President, where their interactions felt natural and heartfelt. However, in My Love Mix-Up! Thailand, that chemistry was left to languish in the background. There were a few standout moments—Kongthap and Atom bonding over their parents’ relationships, Atom sharing his dream of opening a café—but these were few and far between. The series never fully allowed their relationship to flourish, instead opting for contrived conflicts and rushed resolutions.

The romance arc, which should have been the heart of the show, felt forced and unconvincing. Atom’s crush on Mudmee is brushed aside almost immediately, leaving little room for emotional depth. The transition from friendship to romance between Atom and Kongthap lacked the gradual build-up that makes these stories compelling. By the time they became a couple, it felt more like a box had been ticked than a natural progression of their relationship.

Another issue was the pacing. The show tried to cram too much into too little time, resulting in rushed story arcs and unsatisfying conclusions. This is especially evident in Atom’s struggle with his sexuality and his eventual decision to pursue his dream of becoming a chef. Both of these storylines could have been explored in greater depth, but instead, they were wrapped up in a matter of minutes.

Now, it’s not all bad. There were some genuine moments of charm, particularly in the way the series handled the friendship between Atom and Mudmee. Their dynamic was one of the few bright spots in an otherwise uneven show. Additionally, the soundtrack was a highlight—catchy and well-suited to the tone of the series, even if it was a bit overused.

In the end, My Love Mix-Up! Thailand feels like a missed opportunity. With the talent of Gemini and Fourth at their disposal, GMMTV could have created something truly special. Instead, we’re left with a series that, while not without its merits, falls short of the standard set by other Thai BL dramas. For fans of the original manga or the Japanese series, this adaptation might be a bit of a letdown.

As much as it pains me to say it, I can’t rate this any higher than a 5 out of 10. It’s a middling effort that doesn’t quite capture the heart or humor of its source material. Here’s hoping GMMTV takes this as a learning experience and gives these talented actors the scripts they deserve in future projects.

Citeste mai mult

Ricordo ancora quando la gmmtv pubblicò i trailer delle serie che sarebbero uscite quest’anno…mi ero preparata vedendo prima i poster su twitter per poi passare al trailer stesso e ricordo ancora la sensazione avuta quando ho visto il nome della serie e soprattutto gli attori che avrebbero partecipato…una sensazione assurda, stavo per piangere dalla felicità.
A dire la verità ho guardato veramente tante serie e tra quelle giapponesi la mia preferita in assoluto è proprio My Love Mix-Up!, per questo motivo ero veramente contenta e stupita dal fatto che la gmmtv volesse farne una versione thailandese, per di più con protagonisti due attori che stimo e ammiro tantissimo, Gemini e Fourth.
Sin da My School President ho sempre ammirato e amato la loro recitazione e in generale come accoppiata è semplicemente fantastica, non ci sono parole per descrivere quanto sia potente la loro chimica e il modo in cui con loro qualunque serie diventi automaticamente degna di essere vista. Sono molto bravi e talentuosi, è impossibile rimanere delusi da un loro lavoro.
Dato tutto questo amore che provo per loro, ovviamente sapere che una delle mie serie preferite in assoluto sarebbe stata interpretata anche da loro è stata una notizia bomba, qualcosa che veramente non mi sarei mai aspettata e che sicuramente è stata una piacevole sorpresa.

Devo pure ammettere che se non ci fossero stati loro molto probabilmente non l’avrei mai vista perchè sono un pochetto puntigliosa e a me non piace quando fanno versioni di una serie già esistente; non mi piace perchè penso che in un certo senso sia inutile ricreare una serie già esistente, in generale non è che mi cambia tanto se vedo lo stesso identico lavoro con la sola differenza che cambiano gli attori e magari le ambientazioni assumono caratteristiche pochetto differenti. Per questo motivo quando scopro che fanno una versione di una serie che ho già visto non mi scomodo a vederla, non avrebbe senso.
Nonostante questa opinione ho deciso di guardare lo stesso My Love Mix-Up! per il semplice motivo che da fan come sono, non potevo perdermi un nuovo lavoro di Gemini e Fourth. Poi da quando è stata annunciata questa serie ho avuto pure un pò di paura perchè si è incominciato a dire che c’era la probabilità che questo fosse il loro ultimo lavoro assieme; dicevano questo sulla base del fatto che già dai progetti musicali si vedeva un distacco e comunque si vedeva che stessero cercando di concentrarsi su cose diverse da quelle con cui hanno iniziato, quindi non più insieme ma separati. Diciamo che per quanto possa essere vera o falsa questa supposizione, a me non da fastidio che decidano di finire la loro collaborazione etc, possono fare quello che voglio per questo anche se in dolore va bene così. Adesso ovviamente non sto dicendo che succederà, sono solo supposizioni di cui ho sentito parlare e che mi hanno un pò preoccupato. Ho deciso di guardare questa serie per non farmi mancare nulla di loro e se questo rappresenterà un addio almeno posso dire di averli supportati fino alla fine. (sembra che la sto facendo tragica ma fidatevi non è così).

In ogni caso parlando della serie ero un pò pensierosa di come decidessero di farla perchè nella versione giapponese c’erano 10 episodi di una ventina di minuti ciascuno, invece, nella versione thai ce ne sono 12 di almeno 40 min ciascuno, per questo ero sicura si sarebbero inventati qualcosa e così è stato.
Durante i primi episodi la trama si presentava uguale a quella giapponese con l’aggiunta di varie cose per ovviamente occupare maggiore tempo, ma poi la trama è cambiata così tanto che sembrava fosse una serie diversa.
Mi è piaciuto molto il modo in cui hanno mantenuto la trama di base ma cambiando il modo in cui loro si innamorassero, in questa maniera ho potuto sperimentare la visione di una serie a sé, una serie che pur restando fedele a una trama in particolare avesse comunque quella sua luce, così che sembrasse diversa.
Questa cosa mi è piaciuta tanto perchè mi ha fatto godere meglio la visione del tutto.
I cambiamenti che sono stati fatti (in particolare quello del maestro) mi sono piaciuti tutti e ho trovato tutto parecchio originale.

In generale non mi va di entrare nei particolari ma posso dire che mi è piaciuto tutto di questa serie: i personaggi erano completi e fatti bene, in ogni loro sfaccettatura; le coppie sono state tutte affrontate a dovere e nel frattempo abbiamo anche avuto modo di avere a che fare con dinamiche di amicizia, famiglia e futuro.
Posso dire che la gmmtv si è superata in termini di completezza, solitamente lascia sempre delle cose appese, invece qui mi è sembrato tutto abbastanza equilibrato.
Una delle cose che ho amato di più è come abbiano voluto affrontare il tema del non sapere cosa voler studiare all'università. Metto in risalto questo tema perché mi sono veramente rivista in Atom. Lui non sapeva cosa voler fare e questa cosa lo faceva sentire come una specie di emarginato, la pecora nera in mezzo a tante pecore bianche, l’unica a non avere un piano per il proprio futuro. Eppure gli hanno dato coraggio a sperimentare cose così da poter capire cosa potesse piacergli e mi è piaciuto molto come non l’abbiano fatto sentire di meno per questo dubbio. Purtroppo per me questo che sta per iniziare quest’anno è il quinto e ultimo anno delle superiori e ho il suo stesso problema, non credo in generale di farcela e allo stesso tempo anche dopo tutta la fatica non saprò cosa sia meglio per me. Mi piacciono cose differenti ma non ho esperienza in nessuna di queste per questo non mi sento in grado di farcela e poi si può scegliere solo una via. Mentre la decisione è una, io mi ritrovo di fronte tante vie nessuna a me più importante delle altre, la decisione è ardua e nel profondo so che alla fine non voglio impegnarmi in nessuna di queste. Sono bloccata come una scema con la testa tra le nuvole che vorrebbe solo scappare, speriamo che quest’anno mi venga qualche illuminazione sennò è certo che mi pentirò sempre delle mie scelte fatte per indecisione.
Ritornando alla serie posso dire che l’unica pecca è forse il fatto che certe scene sono decisamente tanto cringe o esagerate ma per il resto mi è piaciuto tutto.
Ne consiglio la visione.

Citeste mai mult

The Chemistry is GOOOOD.

We got another adaptation of a Japanese BL into a Thai BL in My Love Mix-up and I will have to say this – THEY ARE DOING REALLY GOOD SO FAR. I mean, the Japanese BL are still GOATED but these stories being adapted for Thai media is giving us more stories about the characters instead. They are trying to put their own culture into it so that is really commendable and it worked. The story still follows the love story of Atom and Kongthap. Kongthap accidentally picked up the eraser that Atom borrowed from his crush but this supposed love triangle was all a misunderstanding. I think we can all agree that this all started as a misunderstanding but it soon led to a really good bond between Atom and Mudmee while Atom was also starting his relationship with Kongthap. So, yes, we have two main lovers in the story. We have the main love story and the supporting love story which is just as great as the main. I don’t say that often but I will say it here – the love story of Mudmee and Half is really good. Well, let us start with the main lovers of the story which are Kongthap and Atom played by Gemini and Fourth. The chemistry is intense with these two and I love that for them. I feel like I have grown a bit distant with Gemini with what he said but I found myself forgiving him in this one because he really played the character of Kongthap really well. He played the straight-laced serious kid really well and giving him nuance that would make you slowly fall in love with him. I think we also need to highlight that people like these do exist and they will need more time to ease with things so I am glad that Atom soon understood that, of course, with the help of Khao Pan. Speaking of Atom, the star of the entire show for me is Fourth as Atom. He is phenomenal and I can’t ask anything more from him. He is the star of this show from the very moment the start to end. I will have to say that what really made me so much in love with the show is his friendship with Mudmee. I know that he initially liked her but the friendship that they were able to build here is the best among all the BLs that I have watched so far. Fourth played the character with so much facial expressions that I am so impressed with his acting. The more emotional stuff might need a bit more polishing but he gave such a wonderful performance that I can forgive him here because it was really entertaining from start to finish. I like how aggressive he is after accepting that he is now in love with Kongthap but still playing this fragile counter to his character. I like it so much. He was so fun to watch. He was so charming that I feel like it is hard to resist a guy like him and the bond that he was able to build with Kongthap did not even feel forced at all. It is a slow burn kind of love story where they became more friends and they are so much lucky to have an older gay couple guiding them through this new relationship that they have. It is not easy to navigate such emotions but the help that they got is really important if you will ask me. I wish that this happens more in real life where we can be more out with ourselves so that we can be in relationships that are consensual and loving. There is something so good about Young Love that I really want to highlight and that is what they were able to capture here especially when they were deciding in which school to study in. There is something so simple yet honest on how this is what they think will be their biggest problem in the world. It is so pure. It is so sincere. It is so romantic. I actually enjoyed it. I think the same can be said with the supporting couple. Half is very handsome. I just want to add that and I think that his relationship with Mudmee had repetitive aspects to it but the portrayal is still very good that I can really forgive them. I mentioned young love earlier and this is just another perfect example of that where they are still trying to figure things out and they are still so unsure of so many things that are happening to them that I think it is very much understandable for them to be confused with how they will be doing things. I think the confusion that they had is still understandable and it is still very cute. The acting is also pretty good that it is working well. I think these young actors did an impressive job with their work that they were able to fully embody these characters well and gave us a feel-good show to watch. I am happy with this and I enjoyed watching it so much.

Citeste mai mult