SUPERIOR A VERSÃO JAPONESA
Assisti Cherry Magic na versão japonesa e logo em seguida iniciei essa para comparar, particularmente eu já tenho tendências a gostar mais dos programas tailandeses e aqui não foi diferente.O sentido da minha nota baixa é que eu não gosto dessa história desde a primeira versão, essa é superior então eu dei uma nota maior mas ainda é uma história ruim pra mim.
Não gosto do nível de infantilidade que Cherry Magic tem, pelo menos nessa versão tivemos beijos e uma cena sexual entre o casal (o que deveria ter na versão japonesa também já que o conceito de ler mentes vem através do sexo).
Gosto de como os problemas são resolvidos mais facilmente aqui deixando uma vibe mais leve e gosto de como adicionaram um pouco mais de textura no Karan, mesmo ele ainda sendo um personagem extremamente negligenciado em conflitos próprios e que gira ao redor do Achi (assim como na versão original).
O excesso de passividade e falta de atitude do Achi irrita tanto que muitas cenas eu tive que pular.
Não existia a necessidade de um terceiro casal na trama e o casal coadjuvante é mais fofo nessa adaptação.
Essa é uma versão melhorada da japonesa mas ainda não faz o meu tipo, eu definitivamente não gosto de Cherry Magic como um todo e não entendo porque as pessoas gostam tanto.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Langweilig
Ich liebte die original Serie aus Japan und hatte hohe Erwartungen. Ich würde leider komplett enttäuscht.Die Geschichte hat mich nicht gepackt. Die Hauptdarsteller auch das BL Nebenpärchen sind meiner Meinung nach schlecht besetzt und ihre Chemie gleich 0. Ich hatte echt Fremdschämen, besonders beim neben BL Pärchen beim anschauen. Das Schiff ist längst gesunken.... Das war leider ein schlechter Versuch das Hauptpaar wieder zu beleben. Schauspielerisch haben sie auch einen mittelmäßiges Ergebnis erzielt. Ich rate allen sich die Zeit zu sparen das anzuschauen. Es gibt 1000 Mal bessere BL Serien. Den Hype drum verstehe ich überhaupt nicht. Ja ich weiß ich werde dafür gehasst von den Fans aber so ist es nun Mal. In Dark blue kiss hatten sie eine hervorragende Leistung. Das war's aber auch schon.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Best COMFORT, SWEET SIMPLE DRAMA...FULL OF LOVE
I usual don't write...this is my second time that I am writing a review.I found this drama really sweet... NO OVERACTING, NO EXTRA DRAMA, NO TOXICITY, NO FORCE OF THINGS TO HAPPEN ...just pure emotions...and understanding for each other.
How is make you comfortable?
KARAN:-
A loves someone for years secretly... without any expectations...
though he waited for this for long time since he respect your emotions, your discomfort, don't force yourself on you, love you the way you are, make you feel special... understand you in every possible way.
ACHI:-
A person who is never been in relationship try to figure out things how he will good in a relationship...
how will not disappoint another person.
Try not to take advantage of another's emotions and feelings.
The thing I love about ACHI AND KARAN relation is they.... RESPECT eachother, they GIVE SPACE to eachother THEY SUPPORT eachother...they try to UNDERSTAND eachother emotions and feelings... THEY DON'T FORCE one to another....
The thing I LIKE THE MOST IS.... is not necessary always you to kiss after your confession...you should give yourself and another time to adjust and adapt the things ( may be most of the people don't like this) you don't have to touchy and have intimacy to show your love...
Your small gesture always show love towards eachother other...
THEY SHOW HOW A RELATIONSHIP GROW SLOWLY...HOW TWO PEOPLE TRUST EACHOTHER AND PROVIDE COMFORT TO EACHOTHER.
MIN & JINTA
they are cute , sweet, a good understanding realation.... ( But I just find a little bit lack of chemistry between them)
ROCK & PAI
they are cutest... Their relation is sweet and spicy.... Even PAI knows Rock feelings are genuine...but she still needs her time and ROCK has no problem in that.
OVERALL THIS DRAMA IS SIMPLE, SWEET, COMFORTABLE...
FILLED WITH LOVE, FRIENDSHIP, UNDERSTANDING, SUPPORTIVE PEOPLE.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Best watched without seeing the original
The is a decent, enjoyable BL from GMMTV - not a stand out but far from the worst.The years that Tay and New have been working together and their friendship shows in the natural chemistry and New gets plenty chances to use his trademark confused/shocked expression!
Where it falls down is when comared to the Japanese original with the comdey seeming more forced than natural. . Ok this is an extended version with more of the story covered but much in the same way that happens when there are american remakes of european series/movies it's ended up being more polished and slick (I'm deseprately trying to avoid saying bland which would be a little too harsh) which causes it t lose character.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Fell off after few eps
It was funny when Achi was confused with wtf was going on in the beginning. But it got very boring after that. The supporting story with mark and junior didn't really cross-over enough with the main story enough I feel and they felt like 2 completely different shows. Also they're fully grown 30 year old men lol. I felt like the it could have been a bit more mature themed but kept it's romcom vibe.Considerați utilă această recenzie?
¡Increíble y maravillosa adaptación!
(Voy a hacerla corta porque lo bueno si es breve es dos veces mejor.)Como amante de la adaptación japonesa, vine a esta adaptación con dudas, miedo e incredulidad.
Me pone muy contenta el poder decirles que esta serie me pegó unos buenos cachetazos y me hizo ver que podían hacer una muy buena adaptación con cambios muy positivos, con música hecha para vibrar con las escenas, con personajes interpretados magistralmente por dos actores que tienen una química aplastante (y sonrisas cautivadoras) y, en general, con un amor y aprecio por una historia de amor simple y tan enorme a la vez.
No soy buena reseñando cosas, pero necesitaba expresar mi felicidad ahora que la serie terminó. Yo, por mí, que la serie durara toda la vida y no me cansaría de verla.
La voy a rever de seguro próximamente. ¡Es una joyita, sin dudarlo! Se ganó un lugar al lado de su contraparte nipona. No puedo decir que esta sea mejor que la otra versión, como así tampoco puedo decir que la versión japonesa sea mejor que esta. Ambas son muy buenas y tienen sus puntos positivos y (un poquito) negativos. Me siento como una madre, no puedo elegir entre uno y el otro porque ambos son especiales en mi corazón. No hay manera de elegir, si debo elegir algo, sería reverlas a las dos. Sí que sí. Todos los años, al menos 1 vez cada una. ¡Jajaja!
En conclusión, háganse el favor de ver esta serie. 100/10.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Candid Charms of TayNew
"Cherry Magic," the Thai adaptation of the popular Japanese BL series, introduces Achi, an ordinary employee who discovers an extraordinary power on his thirtieth birthday – the ability to read minds through physical contact. Portrayed by Newwie, known for his role in "SOTUS" since 2016, it's evident that he has grown as an actor, delivering a commendable performance. His chemistry with Tay, who plays the charming colleague Karan, brings freshness to the screen, particularly for me who's accustomed to seeing Newwie with Earth (my last BL with Newwie starring on it)Tay's portrayal of Karan is engaging, although lacking a point of comparison since I haven't seen him in previous dramas. The storyline follows Achi's struggle to navigate his newfound ability, especially after unintentionally uncovering Karan's feelings for him. While the Thai adaptation stays faithful to the original premise, there are moments where the pacing feels sluggish, making some parts of the series less captivating.
One aspect that stands out is Newwie's handling of intimate scenes. Despite his experience, there's a noticeable awkwardness that detracts from the authenticity of those moments. However, it's worth acknowledging that this could be a result of various factors, including character dynamics and personal comfort levels.
Overall, "Cherry Magic" offers a decent adaptation for fans of the BL genre, with strong performances from its leads. While it may falter in pacing at times, it's a refreshing addition to Thai BL dramas, showcasing both familiar faces and new talent in the genre.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
EymiLaritzaJorgeCastillo
0 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
Serie que ame!!
vaya disfrute esta versión de Cherry Magic mucho mas que la japonesa, quizás sea opinión impopular en ese sentido, pero ame mucho la ejecución de esta y el desarrollo de los personajes y que profundizaron mas (en mi opinión) en algunas escenas que en su versión original, y como dije, ser opinión impopular, pero sin duda la ame.Hace tiempo que quería volver a ver a actuar al TayNew, y se dio esta oportunidad con esta historia tan bella y la verdad es que no decepcionan, la química de estos dos actores me encanta.
Sobre la historia, ya la conocíamos, esta deriva de un manga y una serie japonesa y la verdad es la misma, lo único que se adecua al contexto cultural de Tailandia.
la volvería a ver? pues si, ame muchísimas esta versión, disfrute mucho, seguro sera de las series que vuelvo a ver.
La musica me gusto mucho, algunas ya estas en mi playlist.
Si amaron la japonesa pues disfrutaran esta y si no la han visto, pues no se que esperan, especialmente esta, en mi opinión es de lo mejor.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
A very cute watch.
To be honest when I first watch this drama I was a little bored so I dropped it for a while. A couple months later I came back and tried to rewatch it, and I ended up loving it, though the original cherry magic was definitely better. In my opinion Thailand’s version of it is still very good I really liked the casting of Tay and New And I also loved seeing some new faces. Those some parts are cheesy and hard to watch that just made it all the better. There was one plot at the end that did make me rule down my review just a little bit, The no office romance plot. It didn’t really serve any purpose or really do anything to the story so I found it kind of meaningless but nonetheless it out a little bit of drama into the end if you’re looking for something cute and easy to watch this would definitely be it, but if you’re looking for something with a long plot This probably wouldn’t be it. To be completely honest if Tay and New weren’t in the cast. I probably wouldn’t have went back to rewatch it. but still, I give this drama an 8 (To compare I gave the original cherry magic a 9.5)Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Sweet and soft like a cherry
It was my first TayNew series. I couldn't wait to experience their dynamic. Before that, I only watched series where one of them played a role, but not both together. TayNew did not disappoint me. I enjoyed their couple and Cherry Magic TH in general very much.I have to say that I neither know the manga nor have I seen the Japanese series adaptation, so I can't make a comparison as to which version I like better. Overall the plot is veeeery sweet. It's stress-free, happy, without angst and with many wholesome moments.
Karan and Achi are very cute together. At first they were colleagues and then slowly became more than that. While Karan had a crush on Achi for a long time, Achi was surprised and overwhelmed by it. But Karan's smile and charm quickly became irresistible. The kisses were so soft, I'm still spellbound.
Besides I like Jinta a lot. He is loud, overdramatic and can be annoying, but that's exactly what I find charming and very entertaining. Such a sweet and chaotic dork. I want a bookstore date like JinMin. It looks like so much fun.
And I really like Tanaka! Sometimes I thought he was going to have some kind of nasty surprise for his employees, but in reality he is just funny, nice and understanding. Best boss!
I'm looking forward to more TayNew content in the future!
[finished watching on 3 May 2024]
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Cute and Sweet Pairs
It is a heartwarming and beautiful depiction of how both Achi and Karan fall for each other because of their kindness. There is a warmth to the story’s well-placed humor. And a sincerity in the way it has begun to tell each character’s story. Newwiee is adorable as the fluffy Achi, who despite being a hard-working employee has low self-esteem issues. Tawan is equally good as the dashing Karan, with a blinding smile that has all the office girls weak in their knees. Most of the story unfolds in an office set-up, which was a refreshing change from all the college fluff such series are filled with.Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
