Completat
HannahAli
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
feb 14, 2024
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 10
Poveste 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 10

the mind versus the heart: is loving BOF a moral issue?

yes, this show has aged poorly and has problematic aspects - however I still love it so I don’t understand you haters who made it go down to a 7.5 stars!!! anywho, it’s not about the show itself, but the ability it has through it’s nostalgic music, weird characters,and crazy plot to make you forget about your miserable life. thank you, and watch this show! it won’t improve your life, but the characters’ problems sure will make you forget about yours. #thisOSTslaps #GeunJanDi4theDeathPenalty #allMediaIsProblematicAnyways
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
JasmineAlGendy
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
sep 17, 2016
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 8.5
Poveste 9.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Muzică 9.5
Valoarea Revizionării 5.0
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere
Boys over flowers is the kind of drama that when someone who's new to korean drama asks you which drama should I watch first you find yourself recommending it!
it's based of a Japanese manga called Hana Yori Dango and in my opinion I find most of the dramas based on a manga are fairly successful
this one actually tops the list

ok first the story: it started with a weird plot twist a funny one to be exact I didn't get it but afterwards I found it nice what I didn't like was the cliche story of a poor girl joining a school with rich guys it's not that I hate it but it's almost happening in every korean drama but it didn't bother me as much
I also didn't like the idea that the heroine is way too much tom-boyish and that didn't change until in the second part of the story and I actually have a problem with these type of heroines and the weird thing she's good to only the guy she loves and she screws the rest I won't say more because of spoilers but who watched the drama will get it ..she had an average character development for a tom-boyish girl falling in love and all but personally I'm not a fan of Geum Jan di
as for Goo Joon Pyo the character is a bit cliche but I liked it.. the bad spoiled rich guy turns good after falling in love.. I liked how loyal he is to his girlfriend and how much his acts were acts of true love the ideas and the moments between Jan Di and Joon Pyo were impressively romantic and new.. and as for the character developments Joon Pyo's were the best and So Yi Jung's were the worst..I hated how much heartless he was even after too much moments of showing love he was still a jerk and I don't think normally there is that much of a jerk in somebody towards a girl who treats him nicely
the story gets a 9 because it was a romantic overdose for me which I really liked

Acting: let me first start with Gu Hye Sun because I have a little problem with her showing emotions..first of all I thought the character didn't fit her Jan Di was way too aggressive and Hye Sun's face features didn't show that ..she actually didn't look like a bad girl to me she was the kind that made me laugh every time she made an aggressive move because she was so small and cute to hit guys and being a bad girl
and as for emotional moments Hye sun's problem that she can't separate between how to look sad on the verge of crying face and the Do I look like I care face or more like I feel sad but I just don't give a damn face
Lee Min Hoo is an exceptional actor for me because he's really good at expressing his emotions on his face and actions specially when he's angry
I have a little problem with him overrating sadness and the way he shows it but I think I can pass because his overall good acting makesup for it
I give the acting 8 because of Gu Hye Sun obviously

Music: I won't be overrating when I say this is one of the best Korean drama music of all time and the secret in my opinion that is the songs fit the moments they play in a lot.. which helps you get focused on the scene and what's happening in it.. I still have the music on my current playlist it's one of my favorites I give it a 9.5

Rewatch or not?: I give it a 5 because the drama is way too long for me to rewatch it since I'm the kind of person who rarely rewatch a drama unless I'm waaay too attached to it

overall: this drama is one of Korean dramas classics which means it's a must if you're still new to korean dramas it's one of the best school dramas out there and if you're looking for hardcore Romance this drama is for you I give it an 8.5 and I could've gave it more if the heroine was someone other than Gu hye sun.. hope this was useful ;)

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
Asma Mohammadi
1 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
apr 12, 2017
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 10
Poveste 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 10
This is my favourite serie and everything was perfect in this drama. Thus this show was amazing not from the story itself alone, but from the flawless portrayal from the main characters and the amazing chemistry between Geum Jan Di and Goo Joon Pyo. :)
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
ygpnnn
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
iun 24, 2023
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 1.0
Poveste 1.0
Acting/Cast 1.0
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 8.0

Does not age well, so bad it's almost good

This drama does not age well. I know that this is considered a classic because it was very popular when it was released but this drama is the antithesis of timeless. It is absolutely not timeless even less than 20 years later. It has the most sexist plotline I've ever seen post 1990 and the most horrendous acting performance done by a FL. The only thing this drama has going for it is the OST and its loud late 2000s/2010s fashion style. Everything else in this is absolute garbage and not worth watching after 2010.

I would place this drama in the category of "so bad it's good" like watching the Twilight series. People meme and rewatch Twilight in the United States because it was so bad that it's almost good. I would put BOF in the same category. I gave it a high rewatch value simply because it is so bad, it's entertaining to rewatch and laugh about it because it is so cringe I can barely believe it was real. This whole drama is like a fever dream.

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
50FiftillidideeBrain
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
dec 1, 2023
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 8.0
Poveste 8.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Muzică 8.0
Valoarea Revizionării 8.5

W♡nder-Girl Meets Bad☆Boy☆Band! °8.3° °Excellent°

Wondering if this is worth your time?

If you love Kromcoms, this show is mandatory. If you think romcoms are Daebek, SK or otherwise, you will want to add this one to your list. Here's the test: If you aren't starstruck by ep2's conclusion, just move on; BOF is not for you.

Jun-Pyo may love viewing the skies through his telescope, but BOF isn't intended to be viewed through a high powered one. Lie back, look at the stars and dream a spell. Yes, there's consistency issues, and 2-2-Too much back and forth. Yet, I couldn't stop watching. 25 episodes is a LOT, and yes, it should have been trimmed back. The last vignette is best forgotten; it's that 5th season that never should have been made. Ask Jun-Pyo to hand over a towel in order to wipe that one away.

Additionally, it stretches credulity a tad far when we see these ruthless and cruel overlords of the school all (rather quickly) turn from black holes into North Stars. Actually, the 3 aren't necessarily cruel, but they are indifferent, which is just as bad. Since they were in playpens together, it seems that his 3 quasi underlings just let Jun-Pyo be Jun-Pyo. He is the sole instigator, the solar flare. Jan-di's parents are over the top of Namsam tower extra, but within the sphere of comedies at large. Jan-di has some strange moments in the first 3 or so episodes. She almost looks (clinically) spastic. Obviously, the director was going for laughs, but ultimately gets a "Huh?" None of that is important, though, because this is very Pride and Prejudice (especially if Darcy had an evil queen for a mother) with some Beauty and the Beast stardust thrown in.

Geum Jan-di is a beautiful soul, and Gu Jun-pyo loves her so completely, that I fell for them. Their relationship is lovable... when it's not WWIII, that is. The way they tit-for-tat fight, make up, and merely converse (always addressing each other using full names only, for example) is adorable. The leads did a bang-up job: The attachment feels authentic, and the sparks are visceral. While I haven't seen the lauded Japanese version, Koo Hye-sun is perfect - she's artsy, smart, and still forward-strong: She's a singer-songwriter, actress, director and artist now. I love her Jan-di, except for the loose handful of Red Cards. Lee Min-Ho - Don't dismiss him. He's not a heartthrob merely because he dropped from the sky that way. He built his image one work at a time, and BOF was his big launch to international stardom.

It does make sense that he falls for her, btw. "No" is something he'd never heard. Ever. He's no longer a lone star in upper space looking down on everything. Here comes a moon at his level, orbiting him. He loves the challenge. While engaging in the contest and in partial shock a girl exists that isn't interested in him, Gu Jun-Pyo concludes that Jan-di is the #only light in his sky. He's been denied love and family time, which is what his heart wants most. She blew his mind by standing up to him. He fixates on Jan-di as his panacea, his home. He boorishly pursues her, knowing nothing but bossing people around. He'll grab her arm to drag her somewhere, and she #lets him. She, likely, has no idea why(?!) she lets him. She certainly doesn't want to like him - given how much she °loathes° him. The human heart is a mystery, indeed. If you find his behavior offensive, you're right, but only for a twinkle. Gu Jun-Pyo is a quasar, Jan-di, the red giant. Once their paths collide, the quasar changes course, shooting down to earth. All those episodes find Jan-di schooling Gu Jun-Pyo. He accepts her tutoring and becomes a better, happier, more peaceful man. The opening of the show finds him a veritable toddler - le infantile terrible - throwing tantrums and money at everything that vexes him. Don't think for a moment that he's domineering, abusive, or controlling in the relationship; that ain't what's going down. Jan-di would kick him in the head if she didn't want his attentions. Anyone thinking Gu Jun-Pyo is in the lead is projecting. He enters HER world, and it's endearing. They travel light-years to bond, only to have that bond tested to the extreme. The gravitational pull between them only strengthens as they share any orbit to work through obstacles together.

BOF is an excellent choice for teens. Jan-di is a shining role model. Her beautiful smile elevates all who are in her proximity (except The Witch). She stands for what's right. She is courageous. She's a veritable Joan Of Arc in the battle for Shinwa High- Without the burned-at-the-stake thing. Yet, she can be as comforting as a plate of warm pancakes. The way Gu Jun-Pyo adores her, emitting rays of warmth in which she can bask, should resonate with teenage girls, and prod them to reflect on their standards when it comes to boyfriend material. If you can swim with it and overlook some of the goofy stuff, you will escape to the great beyond with this entire group of friends. You will also be treated to an epic kiss, mid thruway at rush hour, in the background is the sun dropping from the sky, igniting the space between them. Eat your hearts out Sunny, Ginger & Miranda.

The notoriety of the show, which includes its effect on popular culture, plus the fact that BOF boosted Kdramas' popularity globally, as well as the numerous nominations and awards bestowed all supply evidence that this series is WONDER-FUL.

IMHO~》》

Directing 7
Acting 8
Romance 9
Flutters 8
Warmth 7
Art 7
Action 5
Thought provocation 6
Ending 8

For Age 13+ with cautions: Jan-di gets duped into taking fetish photos. She's shown in a childlike skirt and wearing bunny ears. She holds up a revealing costume and refuses to put it on. There are two setups to look like two singles shared a bedroom (to get an enemy in trouble), and there was a lie about a pregnancy scare. These would all be good for generating worthy discussions regarding safety of person and reputation. Decide accordingly.


Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
Lara
1 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
aug 15, 2020
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 3.5
Poveste 2.0
Acting/Cast 3.0
Muzică 7.0
Valoarea Revizionării 1.0

fanfiction live action

empecé el drama con muchas ganas y los primeros capítulos me engancharon muchísimo pero la serie degenera tan rápido y de manera tan surrealista cuesta abajo sin frenos que es insostenible. literalmente tiene todos los clichés de las telenovelas habidos y por haber.

la protagonista principal es insufrible y creo que voy a sentirme triste por ji-hoo toda mi vida.

nota: llegué al final porque salía lee min ho y menos mal que no hay más de 25 capítulos porque hasta a él le estaba empezando a coger manía por culpa del personaje.

menudo bajón de drama.

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
BeaSP
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
dec 30, 2015
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 9.5
Poveste 8.5
Acting/Cast 10
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 9.0
I first started watching ´Boys Over Flowers´ because it appeard on every romantic comedy drama suggestions, so…oh well, i decided to give it a try. Also, since years ago i´ve watched the anime version (Hana Yori Dango) i already knew what was coming around, still… it made me curious how they would produce this story.
I don´t know about the previous live action dramas ( maybe someday i´ll give it a try as well) but I was not expecting this drama version to be soooo good! The producers and the whole cast managed to improve some details of the story telling by focussing on and expanding every characters´ back stories, personalities and emotions in a very charismatic way, unlike the anime version ´Hana Yori Dango´, that payed more atention on the main roles instead.
Not to mention the ost was extremely catchy. Loved it! I coulnd´t stop singing along whenever such songs as ´Paradise´ (Almoooost Paradise! xD), ´Stand by me´, ´Because i´m Stupid´, and ´One more time´came on. They were stuck in my head for days.
The only, tiny thing that i didn´t fully apreciate was the final episodes near the ending.. in my opinion they dragged it a little too much with that unnecessary final obstacle between the main charecters, because let´s be honest, they already had enough throughout the entire show. However, it was still a great ending.
Now, some of you might be asking: Is it worth a rewatch? My answer is definitely. Every element present in it is what makes it a classic in the history of dramas. So if you have it in your ´Plan to watch´ list or are considering to add it, then don´t miss it.

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
☆(ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
apr 15, 2023
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 7.0
Poveste 8.0
Acting/Cast 6.5
Muzică 7.5
Valoarea Revizionării 4.5
Această recenzie poate conține spoilere

Personal Review

It was a solid show, but the ending was a little disappointing, especially with the plot of characters leaving 4 years instead of staying with each other. Also, the father kind of just... Left? I assume it's because something happe ned to the actor, but it was a bit weird. I wish things would've gone more nice for Geum friend. She was left without answers and heart broken too many times. Yi-jeong should've treated her better. I wanted that ship to SAIL! Gu and Geum communication was terrible, which led them to having more problems. It's almost like Geum would've been better Ji Hoo, her "soulmate." I wasn't really attracted to him, but I wish he was given more a chance in the story. I wish Gu's mother would've honestly apologize for all the harm she did, but she literally did nothing. Very disappointed. She was one of the main reason why Gu and Geum kept breaking up! Overall, the character I would I say I fit the most in is Song Woo-bin. He plays as a side character in the story and doesn't have a strong personality like the others, but just like him I would probably be on the sidelines trying to help with others relationship. I wouldn't per say "beat people up," but if I had to, I would. I wish he had more of a character arc. He poses as goofy, which I am, and hangs out with Yi-jeong; which I would love to do. Also, he's a great dancer, if you know whattaaaa I MEANNAN.

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
Amy
1 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
sep 18, 2015
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 8.5
Poveste 8.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Muzică 8.0
Valoarea Revizionării 10
This was the first Kdrama I ever saw and I've just loved it ever since~! In fact, I already re-watched it and kind of want to watch it again... Yes, it is quite long and near the end it gets a little... of track? But still, I just adore this drama and would recommend it any day~~ especially to people who are new to Kdramas~!! This is a MUST watch~~ ^^
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
zensx_MDL
2 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
ian 28, 2024
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 6.5
Poveste 6.5
Acting/Cast 6.5
Muzică 6.5
Valoarea Revizionării 6.5

Boys Over Flowers (2009)

The show has essentially become a cult classic over the years. For many, it was their first foray into the K-Drama scene and thus carries a strong sense of nostalgia and reminiscence.

But it should really stop there.

Cliché after cliché , trope after trope, stereotype after stereotype. Iffy characters at best trying to navigate their way around a wildly over the top plotline. It romanticizes unhealthy relationships that offer heavy emotional baggage with little to no payoff. Without a doubt, the show's core is an ugly mess protected by its presentation and production values.

Ironic, since it claims to prefer boys over flowers.

Citeste mai mult

Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
malkael
6 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
mai 6, 2014
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 10
Poveste 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 10
I think its the best kdrama for everyone in each age ...
Its amazing and heart crashing ;)
All the cost are good and hardworking with full of feeling.
This is the greatest kdrama that everyone specially kdrama lovers must watch
No one forget jandi, junpyo & jihoo
Just watch watch watch
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Completat
erwinjen
5 oamenii au considerat această recenzie utilă
aug 14, 2013
25 of 25 episoade văzute
Completat 0
Per total 10
Poveste 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muzică 10
Valoarea Revizionării 10
I thought the drama was awesome except for the first two episode and half of the last episode. Regardless of what everyone has said about this drama, to us it was great. There are quite a few tears shed by my wife on this drama. We even watch the drama over again and was hooked again. Geum Jan Di's character to us was acted well, she made us feel for her, given her situation. She displayed a strong willed character that went against all odds, of course, with help from the F4.
Considerați utilă această recenzie?
Boys Over Flowers (2009) poster

Detalii

Statistici

  • Scor: 7.5 (Marcat de 1 utilizator)
  • Clasat: #5790
  • Popularitate: #12
  • Spectatori: 167,159

Principalii Contribuabili

101 edita
79 edita
76 edita
39 edita

Liste Populare

Liste înrudite de la utilizatori
Live Action Shoujo Manga
243 titles 372 loves 6
Rich Guy/Poor Girl
118 titles 179 loves 2
Favorite Dramas - Happy End
262 titles 163 loves 13

Recent vizionat de